DISQUS

Marketing Pilgrim: Top 10 Business Mistakes Search Marketing Firms Make

  • Georgi Georgiev · 3 years ago
    Andy, I track your blog for more than a year now, but I never felt like leaving a comment. This time I do. And it is "What a great post Andy!". You pinpoint very very painful areas of Search Marketing and the problems the people in the business face. I'm one of them and I have had the experiences you describe. Some I solved, others - not, but I never had it like that - clear and ordered in my head. Thanks for that post!
  • Igor Mordkovich · 3 years ago
    Andy, very good post. I see you've touched on few points I wrote on my blog about "SEO companies being underpaid" here http://www.bizmord.com/Blog/archives/103 ... don't know if you read it.
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Georgi, thanks for your kind words. I'm glad to have helped.

    Hi Igor, I didn't read you post, but will now! ;-)
  • Jim · 3 years ago
    Nice! - Yes, some of these points you hit home with me a few weeks ago when you came for consulting. (and I'm glad I got tons more details and solutions as well from your consulting)
    Great Post!
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Thanks Jim - of course, the consulting service comes with a lot more detail and solutions. ;-)
  • TopRank · 3 years ago
    Well done Andy. Glad to see you offering up some of that wisdom of yours!
  • Daniel R · 3 years ago
    Andy,

    So what are the most common problems are you seeing out of all? What are the most difficult.

    I would venture to say that the most common and difficult are:

    #3 - Their Business Doesn’t Scale
    #7 - They Rely On One “Expert� to Provide All Client Recommendations
    #8 - Client Information is Silo’d

    What are your thoughts?

    Cheers,

    Daniel
  • Kalena · 3 years ago
    Brilliant post Andy. Would make a great article (-;
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    An article you say? Never thought of that! ;-)
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Good question Daniel. I would say having a business that doesn't scale and not taking care of existing clients, are the two biggest issues. Pricing of services is also a big one.

    There are many more, so maybe I'll do a follow-up with numbers 11-20. ;-)
  • Mikkel deMib Svendsen · 3 years ago
    Your post is good, Andy, but a lot of the advice is only really usefull if you want to grow a larger company. I, for one, am not sure I really do. I simply don't like working in a large company - so why build one? I like working in a small tight group - just a handfull of close people :)

    Having a different goal than growing a large company also (almost) automatically removes a lot of the problems you (so rightly) describe - such as doing sales pitches at conference presentations. I've never done that because I am not selling anything. In fact, I don't really want to take on too many new clients :)

    Money is nice, no doubt, and with the houly rate I (and other "profiled" SEOs) can charge I could probably make more than I do. But in recent years I come to realize that there are just more important things than work and money - for one, my family, my wife and kids. With a high hourly rate, very selective (and few) clients, I can make more than most people and only work very little. Having that as a goal totally change the top 10 mistakes one can make (because you can, off course, still make mistakes - large or small).

    Anyway, you post was good, Andy - I just wanted to point out that there are other valid goals in the life of a good SEO than growing a larger firm :)
  • Paul Zhao · 3 years ago
    Here's one, make employees take pride in their work. An employee's performance should be judged by the "quality" of the work, such as conversion rate from this page copy, or ROI from the SEO/SEM effort. It shouldn't be judged on the quantity such as "how many pages of keyword analysis the person did last week".
  • Brian Gilley · 3 years ago
    Now what's wrong with “Bronze�, “Gold�, “Platinum�, and “Platinum Plus?� ;^) LOL

    Those marginally beat the "Super Deluxe" and "Would you like fries with that?" SEO service package names.

    Honestly, I used a few quirky (gay) names for services back in the day.

    Your #1 - Charging a set up fee: I always find the monthly payment scenario the best for everyone and often compare it to a "hosting plan" when talking or emailing potential clients. Paying for SEO really should be like paying for hosting. I mean. come on - who would pay for a year's worth of hosting from 'xyz' hosting company without knowing uptime, support, and other problems that might occur? The same should go for SEO, at least until they're comfortable with the level of services and work being performed.
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Mikkel,

    Thanks for stopping by and providing your thoughts. I certainly agree that those that are content to keep their business small, often don't face all of the issues I highlighted - in fact, they sometime have their own, which I am learning now that I am a consultant.

    That being said, I think it makes sense for every small business to review the items I listed. A lot of them do apply to companies that want to grow, but they also apply to those that wish to stay small. For those, my advice helps them to be more efficient, which would allow them to have a greater work/life balance.

    Andy
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Paul,

    That's a great addition to the list and one that is just as important. I think also comes back to the "silo" of information I mentioned. SEO staff need to feel that they are making a difference to a campaign and not just expected to "churn" out deliverables.

    I'd much rather measure performance based upon client satisfaction, than number of deliverables.

    Andy
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Brian,

    Long time no see! ;-)

    I agree that insisting on a set-up fee makes it a lot harder to win a new client. With many companies already burned by at least one SEO campaign, a company that removes that fear, will more easily win the business.

    Andy

    PS. I should have recommended services be called "Regular", "Biggie" and "Super-Sized" ;-)
  • Mary Bowling · 3 years ago
    I think most common business mistake - not just for SEM's, but for all types of enterprises - is treating employees like commodities instead of like respected business partners. Set up systems where, if your bottom line grows, they profit, as well. Make your success their success and they become totally motivated to help the business prosper.
  • Tammi · 3 years ago
    Dear Andy,
    Thank you for highlighting these familiar issues. Can you talk more about, or give an example of, an SEM firm that scalable? To me, scalable and replicable means a certain amount of "cookie cutter" processes that must be followed. I use the term "cookie cutter" in a positive way here. The difficulty I have as the head of a small SEM firm is that we spend alot of time customizing for small clients. We want to grow by adding larger clients, and I have the franchise mindset but I'm not sure where to focus...
  • Tim · 3 years ago
    I totally agree!! I have worked for a few SEO companies but the last fitted this description down to a key. They had a steady income but were not looking to expand, then 3 of their only decent SEO programmers left leaving them in bit of a situation. I think every mistake you have outlined here was based around their company. What worries me is, how many other companies out there are making these mistakes too? Hence why I freelance now.
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Tammi,

    When I consult with SEM firms, there is never a single recommendation for how they can scale their business.

    I certainly don't advocate a templated SEO campaign for clients, but the way you structure internal teams, training, rewards and some of the more routine task, is how you are able to replicate each team and grow the business.

    That's the teaser version. ;-)
  • ST · 3 years ago
    Fine! I have made always first mistake.
  • ContrarianLuddite · 3 years ago
    As a consultant I totally related to every word of your article. The Bronze, Platinum etc especially hit home with me - I had consulted for a company who was so intent on having the "special names" and forget what the customer wanted.

    I was repeatedly saying the customers wanted "XX" and they were too busy color coding packages (which they changed, I swear, daily).

    They also were not delivering at all what was being promised to customers I had brought in.

    After losing several pending clients due to the company's total disregard for their needs and wants- and then the company having the gall to say I had not brought them any clients recently - I walked out of that consulting position as fast as I could.

    I'll be reading more of your posts - this was my first visit here.

    Regards,
    ContrarianLuddite
  • SEM Basics · 3 years ago
    This was a great post. I must admit, when I read the title I didn't think I was going to learn much, but your ideas are really solid and useful. I particularly liked the one about pricing. I had taken it as a given that charging a set-up fee was both essential (for the time and effort involved in setting up a campaign) and intelligent (as it provided a nice sum of money). I now see that it can be detrimental. Still, I wonder if one should charge for the time and labor involved. I imagine that one can just raise their montly rates a bit to compensate for the time and effort involved in setting up a campaign. Particularly if the client is locked into a long-term contract. By the way, do you approve of securing a "long-term" contract with a client (let's say, 6 months or a year)? Obviously it is nice to have guaranteed income for a period of time, but are there any down sides that you are a ware of? I'd be interested to here your opinion.

    In the meantime, please keep the good posts coming.

    All the best,
    Moshe
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Hi Moshe,

    I make different recommendations, based upon other aspects of an SEO firms operations. It would be hard for me to make a suggestion that would fit all business models.

    If you'd like to set-up a personalized consultation - with recommendations tailored to your business - I'd be happy to do so.

    Thanks for reading!
  • Manoj Aravindakshan · 3 years ago
    Great points. In addition to client information being siloed, the other aspect I find often is that SEM/ SEO are viewed as "all-by-itself" techniques, without considering that ultimately it is meeting certain business/ marketing objectives.
  • Hobo · 3 years ago
    An good read and one I will be comparing close with our business model.

    We're a very young company and the problem were dealing with is too much work - a problem i think you never really dealt with in the body of your article.

    When do you expand? what are the pitfalls young companys should expect? what are the measures for good expansion, from 2 - 10 employees.
  • Brian Turner · 3 years ago
    Funny that - I've often felt concerned about giving too much away simply on blogs and forums - but you've done exactly what you preached in 9., and already I'm thinking:

    "I can do some of this myself. But obviously this guy knows more and is more valuable to work with."

    Great posts - blogrolled at Platinax. :)
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    Thanks Brian!
  • David Ogletree · 3 years ago
    I would like to expand the first point. Not only should they not have a setup fee they should keep the contract short. Whatever you want to get paid should be split up on shorter contracts. Don't try to get really low monthly payments. Don't set your smallest contract over a year for $100 a month. When you make long contracts your giving out free loans.

    I would also like to know what you think of automatically adding ppc to an SEO contract. Like saying that a certain percentage of the contract goes straight to PPC for every client.
  • Andy Beal · 3 years ago
    David, there are some creative ways to put together campaigns that include a mix of PPC and SEO, under one budget.
  • David Ogletree · 3 years ago
    I understand that I have just seen people just have a certain set % that is the same on all contracts.
  • Barry · 2 years ago
    Hello Andy.
    This is a great article. Its of much help and an eye opener in its unique way. Thank you and keep up the good work.
    Barry
  • Nikolina-Croatia · 2 years ago
    Dear Andy,

    I am from Croatia, and I am thinking of opening my own Marketing and Sales Consulting Firm (while in Croatia there's none, and I am pretty into it;-))...I agree on all statements, but it will pass at least 3 more years till people start realizing what is actually their problem, and start improving and upgarding current adventages instead of inventing new ones...well people do not devote too much time to develop strategies, or they simply do not get it....
  • Dmitri-Moldova · 2 years ago
    Miss/Mrs. Nikolina

    I live in a country, which is just about the same as yours (I doubt, however you'll ever read my comment...) and SEO is something I am interested in for about 7 months. Many of the field experts think that this is nothing, and I agree, but I am eager to grow and to start a SEO business in my country. The Internet infrastructure there is rather poor, and people would hardly know what does a Search Engine mean, but I hope they'll soon understand and I'll be there for them, trying to avoid the point Andy described. Don't think that I live in a 'cave'-country. People do know what is Internet, but for many businesses a Web page in many cases doesn't mean anything.

    I wish I could participate in that SEO article competition, but unfortunately, I don't have many chances with my 7 months of experience. I will try though...
  • Carol · 2 years ago
    I do understnd the problems but what i feel that a problem arises only when there is a solution following it. We need to sit and think about it and find the solution in this case online marketing is a best way of seo.
    http://www.netincomeplace.com
  • George Theodorakis · 2 years ago
    Great Article Andy especialy when you are new in the market you can learn or correct things in your business enviroment.

    Keep up on Good work
  • scott · 2 years ago
    Ok, i kinda have another view on some of these issues.

    I would never do seo by the month. We spend WAY to much time in the initial optimization, design of the optimization structure, research etc. We charge 3k up front, and i would not do a job for a penny less. Perhaps this is because we physical SEO redesign that actually takes design and programming time, apart from the normal SEO.

    I think you should get as much as you can, so you have the resources to have success. I agree with the names Andy points out, it does make your options seem cheesy.

    As for as month by month goes:

    I require a one year commitment, and would never change it. Again, we put too much time, and too much value is received to let a customer see results and leave, thinking the results would continue. In fact we would strip out all SEO on termination, as it is our view that the work we are doing is ongoing and includes weekly updates mandatory for success...if a client leaves (like a membership) they should not continue to get your SEO infrastructure.

    This all leads to perceived value IMO. I thin the biggest mistakes made by SEO firms is charging to little and de-valuating the services. SEO can make a company double their revenues, so i would not rent it month to month. Just my 2 cents... I did find many very interesting points in your article. thanks.
  • sky · 2 years ago
    "Former Porn Webmaster Sees The Light...Well, Mostly."
  • Owen · 2 years ago
    @Scott: I'm surprised at your comment "In fact we would strip out all SEO on termination". If a client has paid you to optimise their website are you saying you would revert it to an older version if they stopped paying your retainer ?
  • SEM Mexico · 2 years ago
    Hello Andy, great article!
    The number one error says everything, the clients expect many things from a SEM company, and if the first thing you tell them is about a setup fee, is like putting a wall between you and them. Why don’t give them a free consultation, the only thing that you’ll probably lose is a couple hours of your time, but you will win the confidence from them.
  • Hobo SEO · 2 years ago
    An excellent post and a worthwhile read time and time again.
  • Jeremiah · 2 years ago
    I have read this post now for about the 11th time. I love it Andy. Thanks!
  • ceviri · 2 years ago
    Good question Daniel. I would say having a business that doesn’t scale and not taking care of existing clients, are the two biggest issues...
  • emlak · 2 years ago
    Good question Daniel. I would say having a business that doesn’t scale and not taking care of existing clients, are the two biggest issues.
  • ege · 2 years ago
    Great Article Andy, thanks for writing.
  • Prince · 2 years ago
    Andy, really your tips are quite interesting. I hope some of this helps!
  • jeremiah · 2 years ago
    I promise you this will work. It helped me a lot when I first read these 10 mistakes because the first company I knew about in seo was Internet Advancement. They are obviously no example to follow. Thanks again Andy!
  • Victor · 2 years ago
    Even if it was said a lot times, i Thank you for this great Article Andy, have needed some nice tips.
  • resim · 2 years ago
    Great Article Andy especialy when you are new in the market you can learn or correct things in your business enviroment.

    Keep up on Good work
  • sohbet · 2 years ago
    perfect article i like this page and bookmarked i will learn more things from here..
  • küresel ısınma · 2 years ago
    An excellent post and a worthwhile read time and time again.
  • Peter · 2 years ago
    What are your thoughts on pricing for PPC set up and management? Wouldn't an initial set up fee and ongoing monthly management fee be suitable in this case?
  • msn ifadeleri · 2 years ago
    I promise you this will work. It helped me a lot when I first read these 10 mistakes because the first company
  • Hip Hop Klamotten · 2 years ago
    To be honest I hate quotes in HTML. Particularly when I’m coding in php using sql queries. Of course it’s not difficult at all, but sometimes it drives me nuts when I am debuggin script and the error occures because of those quotes.
  • Eksis Kurutma Makineleri · 1 year ago
    Thank you my friend for your useful article.
  • jitmillions · 1 year ago
    I just started internet marketing about a year ago and found that search engine optimization is the way to go. I post to my blog regularly and submit articles to article directories when I can.
  • ilanlar · 1 year ago
    An excellent post and a worthwhile read time and time again.
  • resimler · 1 year ago
    thankss so much
    I just started internet marketing about a year ago and found that search engine optimization is the way to go. I post to my blog regularly and submit articles to article directories when I can
  • Kurtlar Vadisi Pusu · 1 year ago
    Great Article Andy, thanks for writing.
  • Aaron · 1 year ago
    I loved it. I posted the list on http://listdid.com. you should post your lists in the future on listdid.com
    - Aaron
  • Güzel Resimler · 1 year ago
    An excellent post and a worthwhile read time and time again..
  • Dan Root · 1 year ago
    While I don't think I will continue this forever... I find that not requiring a contract seems to help those who have already been burned by other firms offering SEO services they cannot fulfill. I would imaging most young firms that are capable of the work and can show some results would benefit from not requiring a contract. Once you become more established, you would need one to help filter client requests. Until then, do the job, and there is no reason for the client to stop paying.
  • alaturqa · 1 year ago
    Thanks perfect post

    alaturqa's last blog post..Taraftalardan 16 numara talebi!
  • kadinca · 1 year ago
    Thanks great post. I like this.
  • Örgü · 1 year ago
    Money is nice, no doubt, and with the houly rate I (and other “profiled” SEOs) can charge I could probably make more than I do

    Örgü's last blog post..Oyun Oynamayı Öğrenmek
  • Yemek Tarifleri · 1 year ago
    Great Article Andy, thanks for writing.

    Yemek Tarifleri's last blog post..Minestra (Minestrone)
  • esanjor · 1 year ago
    Many thanks for the great information guys.
  • oktay usta · 1 year ago
    oktay usta


    It is a good site for healt
    I advice everybody
  • toys · 1 year ago
    Some businesses are best left when they reach the amount of money that the owners/investors wanted from it. This is because the business may be part of a larger group that wants to indulge in some experimentation etc. and they like to use the consistent business to bring in the money. Like a bread-and-butter sort of business. Growing it means higher costs, greater risks etc. So, there are reasons for those ambitions and I think it's okay to make a decision (like companies like Ferrari have done) where they say : “Ok, this is where we wanted to take it and we're going to let it stay here and no further.”
  • kuresel isinma · 1 year ago
    Thank you.
  • LADwebdesign · 1 year ago
    Great article. Even though it's almost 3 years, it is still relevant today. I tailor my contract/services based on who the client is and what their business entails.
  • Gayrimenkul · 1 year ago
    Great site with very good look and perfect information… Thanks!

    Gayrimenkul's last blog post..Toki kamu binalarinida yapacak
  • Holzspielzeug · 1 year ago
    Cool that is what i was looking for!
    Enjoyed reading it. Thanks
  • Kochmesser · 1 year ago
    Great article, great site. Perfect information for me. Keep up the good work! Thank you very much
  • craig mclaughlan · 1 year ago
    interesting article, i like your point about concentrating too much on new clients at the expense of current clients.

    if you can take such great care of existing clients that you'll almost never lose one, then their recommendations alone will create a climate for uninterrupted growth AND you'll be creating a legacy with rock-solid goodwill that can be sold or passed on.
  • namii · 1 year ago
    Beal because of the free information he gave me a while back and continues to give me
  • Jayson · 1 year ago
    Where has this article been? Amazing article Andy - truly good for any business.
  • Dave · 1 year ago
    I think each client should have a tailor made campaign, as you say - it's often niche markets that can get the best results and not just big keyword terms and that's what you rightly poit out in 5 & 6.
    I think the first part of a campaign needs to be a listening excercise - no-one knows the business better than the (potential) client, and that's where you always need to start.

    Great article!
  • Pixelim Media · 1 year ago
    Nice tricks, everyone should read this article for knowing what to do in Search Marketing.